martes, 28 de octubre de 2008

Book Thief Question Part 3 :)

In Liesel's case, stealing is not completely wrong since stealing food is the only way she can survive. The circumstances that Liesel is living through do change the idea of stealing, since her foster parents barely have food to maintain the family. Liesel's life has been very complicated. Her brother died, and then her mother took her to a foster home. Her foster parents live in a small house, have barely enough food to eat and Liesel does not get the best education. Stealing is the only choice Liesel and Rudy have in order to eat. Also, since Liesel does not gave a good education, she may not know the meaning of stealing, or if stealing is right or wrong. Stealing is wrong and it is a sin, but stealing is the only choice Liesel and Rudy have to survive. But if it is the only choice they have ot survive, they had to steal food. We have to remember that they don't receive the best education, so they might have not thought what they were doing. Maybe the fruits they stole where the farmer's food for his family, bur they did not think on that. They just thought of eating and surviving. It is true that Liesel has many other options in order to receive and have money to buy food, but when you are dying of hunger, stealing might be your number one choice or the first idea that comes to your mind. If Liesel had a better education, then she would understand stealing better and would know it is bad.

2 comentarios:

alopezbarton dijo...

Lucia you make some good points but careful when bringing religion into the equation as we do not know what Liesel believes as far as what is and is not sinning. Otherwise you make some good points, but you leave me wondering. If someone is not educated does that excuse them from anything bad they do? Whose responsibility is it to educate them? School? Home? Church?

Ileanaa Berkeley.. dijo...

lulu.. i think you made excellent points and i cant counter argue you.. you mentioned positive and negative.. in a way.. but they dont really have a religion do they? so they dont know its a sin!